SociologyMag
  • Everyday Sociology
  • Academic Sociology
    • Subject Areas
      • Sociological Perspectives
        • Marxism
        • Symbolic Interactionism
      • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
      • Sociology of Disability
      • Sociology of Education
      • Sociology of Family
      • Sociology of Body & Health
      • Sociology of Identity
      • Sociology of Inequalities
      • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Power
      • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
      • Sociology of Religion
      • Sociology of Sexuality & Gender
      • Sociology of Social Exclusion
      • Sociology of Social Movements
      • Sociology of Stratification
      • Sociology of Technology
      • Sociology of Work
    • Research Methods
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Publications & Resources
      • Bibliographies
    • Conferences & Events
  • The Interlocutor
  • Dictionary
    • A
    • B
    • C
    • D
    • E
    • F
    • G
    • H
    • I
    • J
    • K
    • L
    • M
    • N
    • O
    • P
    • Q
    • R
    • S
    • T
    • U
    • V
    • W
    • X
    • Y
    • Z
  • About
    • How to Use This Site
    • Write For Us
    • FAQ
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
  • Everyday Sociology
  • Academic Sociology
    • Subject Areas
      • Sociological Perspectives
        • Marxism
        • Symbolic Interactionism
      • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
      • Sociology of Disability
      • Sociology of Education
      • Sociology of Family
      • Sociology of Body & Health
      • Sociology of Identity
      • Sociology of Inequalities
      • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Power
      • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
      • Sociology of Religion
      • Sociology of Sexuality & Gender
      • Sociology of Social Exclusion
      • Sociology of Social Movements
      • Sociology of Stratification
      • Sociology of Technology
      • Sociology of Work
    • Research Methods
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Publications & Resources
      • Bibliographies
    • Conferences & Events
  • The Interlocutor
  • Dictionary
    • A
    • B
    • C
    • D
    • E
    • F
    • G
    • H
    • I
    • J
    • K
    • L
    • M
    • N
    • O
    • P
    • Q
    • R
    • S
    • T
    • U
    • V
    • W
    • X
    • Y
    • Z
  • About
    • How to Use This Site
    • Write For Us
    • FAQ
    • Contact Us
No Result
View All Result
SociologyMag
No Result
View All Result
Home Everyday Sociology News & Politics

Using NHS or Education Services? Shame On You!

Dr Brian Waldock by Dr Brian Waldock
January 24, 2023
in News & Politics
A A
nhs heart

Photo by Nicolas J Leclercq on Unsplash

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

A number of media outlets today are running with the, typically derogatory, headline that a record number of people in the UK are “dependent on the state” (see here, here, here, and here). By “dependant on the state” what they are referring to is the again derogatory idea of so called ‘benefits dependency’. 

ADVERTISEMENT

In each outlet, the article was published verbatim and focused on an analysis of ONS (Office for National Statistics) figures by the think-tank Civitas. Civitas is registered at the notorious 55 Tufton Street, an address known for its right-wing, ideologically aligned resident think tanks. Civitas is considered centre-right and free-market endorsing according to Antonio Olmedo and Stephen J. Ball.

I was particularly drawn to the following paragraph:

Civitas analysis of Office of National Statistics (ONS) data from 2020/21 showed a record 54.2% of individuals – or 36 million people – now live in households which received more in benefits – including non-cash ones such as NHS and education services – than they contributed in taxes.

On scan reading this paragraph one may be forgiven for missing it, particularly if perusing the news online. To me, it stuck out like a sore thumb: NHS and education services. To many, this may seem uneventful, but to the sociologist’s eye there is much going on.

Benefits Stigma

Benefits, and welfare in general, has long been a contentious issue, especially in Britain and more especially under neoliberal dominance. Scott Lavery’s phenomenally good chapter ‘The Coalition’s ‘Two Nations’ Hegemonic Project’ in his book ‘British Capitalism After the Crisis’ deftly outlined the purposeful building of antagonistic relations between social demographics by the Conservative Party. In layman’s terms, it essentially explains how the better off were conditioned to hate those reliant on benefits for income.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ever since this stirring up of hatred, although it was nothing new as history shows, there has been a bubbling undercurrent of negative attitudes towards those on benefits. However, in recent times, most likely due to the cost-of-living crisis we are being subjected to, and the major job losses occurring throughout the pandemic, attitudes towards benefits have been softening slightly. Although this trend has been occurring since 2016, attitudes to welfare remain harsh, most likely due to the consistently negative framing of welfare in the media such as the way it is described in this article.

Unfortunately, stigma and shame still play a major role in the perceptions of those on benefits. The ever-persisting ‘scrounger’ narrative, the ridiculous idea that those who claim benefits are lazy, or the notion that those on benefits embody some kind of immorality continue to adorn comments across the both the media and social media landscapes.

Narratives

So, what does this have to do the above quotation? The answer is a lot! It is perhaps the first time I have seen both NHS and education services being attached to the narrative of welfare dependency. It is maybe unsurprising given how close we are to losing the NHS to a fully privatised system. Only yesterday Sajid Javid was calling for people to pay for access to GPs and A&E. In addition to the NHS, the conservative party have made it clear that academisation of schools is the goal. Yet, academisation is itself the middle point on the way to a fully private system of schooling in the UK.

It seems then, that perhaps we are about to witness the new tactic to help dismantle and fully privatise the NHS and education by framing them as something that ‘scroungers’ or the ‘lazy’ and ‘feckless’ use. The idea of welfare dependency alone implies weakness and a lack of self-sufficiency, an unacceptable sin the neoliberal world. It, of course, ignores any prior contribution that people may have made into those same welfare provisions that we all pay tax for in the first place.

I expect that it is more than a coincidence that the media chose to run with the welfare dependency headline surrounding the analysis by Civitas especially when there was a much more interesting story being told within the report that was completely ignored. One that reveals another side of the story.

The Middle-Classes

The report by Civitas states:

And for the first time ever, in 2020/21 the middle quintile receives more in benefits now than they paid in tax. In contrast, in 2016/17 they paid over £3,500 more in tax than they received.

This is a massive detail to ignore. By ‘middle quintile’ they are referring to a certain demographic. For reference, the top quintile is the highest 20% of earners with the bottom quintile being the lowest earning 20%. The middle quintile by contrast then is the middle 20% of earners. This essentially translates into the middle-classes. In terms of income, the OECD consider a person earning 75%+ of the median income as middle class. The median income for the UK year ending 2021 was £31400.

This suggests that the middle classes are becoming more reliant on welfare. In other words, if we play devils advocate and include NHS and education services as welfare, then the middle-classes need the benefits system, the NHS and education more than ever before. The middle-class comfortable lifestyle is disappearing. If the dependency narratives are anything to go by, perhaps we will see another incarnation of Lavery’s ‘Two Nation Hegemonic Project’ targeted towards demonising those who use the NHS for free by setting them against those who have been forced to pay, particularly if they implement a means tested system at the first incarnation. After all, in neoliberal logic, it makes sense to hate those who get it for free and gives one a sense of moral superiority to the extent where they can say ‘why should I pay for somebody else’s healthcare’ just like they say ‘why should I pay for somebody to sit at home watching sky TV and languishing on benefits’? Except now, the middle-class may just be drawn into that same narrative.


References

Binding, L. (2023). Patients should be charged for GP appointments and A&E visits to ease waits, Sajid Javid says. [online] Sky News. Available at: https://news.sky.com/story/patients-should-be-charged-for-gp-appointments-and-a-e-visits-to-ease-waits-sajid-javid-says-12791533 [Accessed 23 Jan. 2023].

Butt, S., Clery, E. and Curtice, J.(eds.) (2022), British Social Attitudes: The 39th Report. London: National Centre for Social Research

DeSmog (n.d.). 55 Tufton Street. [online] DeSmog. Available at: https://www.desmog.com/55-tufton-street/ [Accessed 23 Jan. 2023].

‌Knox, T. and Lilley, D. (2023). An analysis of the effects of taxes and benefits on household income. [online] Civitas. London: Civitas. Available at: https://civitas.org.uk/content/files/State-dependency-FINAL.pdf [Accessed 23 Jan. 2023].

Lavery, S. (2019). British Capitalism After the Crisis. Palgrave Macmillan.

‌Olmedo, A., & Ball, S. J. (2015). Competition, governance and global education policy. In Evaluating European Education Policy-Making (pp. 25-52). Palgrave Macmillan, London.


External Reading

El-Gingihy, Y. (2019). How to dismantle the NHS in 10 easy steps. Winchester, Uk: Zero Books.‌

Hernando, M.G. (2019). British think tanks after the 2008 Global Financial Crisis. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan.

Knox, T. and Lilley, D. (2023). An analysis of the effects of taxes and benefits on household income. [online] Civitas. London: Civitas. Available at: https://civitas.org.uk/content/files/State-dependency-FINAL.pdf [Accessed 23 Jan.

Lavery, S. (2019). British Capitalism After the Crisis. Palgrave Macmillan.


Tags: Benefits StigmaEducationNews AnalysisNHSWelfare Dependency
Next Post

Andrew Tate and Male Conformity

Dr Brian Waldock

Dr Brian Waldock

Brian has a PhD in sociology. His thesis focused on a range of concepts including platonism, bureaucracy, and abstract space. When not destroying his mind with theories, he indulges in the occasional video game, anime, chinese takeaway, or maybe even a very rare pint.

Related Posts

NHS Privatisation, Necropolitics, Intentional Killing

by Dr Brian Waldock
July 6, 2023
0
A human skull and its relfection set against a black background

Behind NHS privatisation lies necropolitical choices.

Read moreDetails
Next Post
Andrew Tate

Andrew Tate and Male Conformity

A stsatue of Karl Marx in Chemnitz

What is Marxism?

BSA Logo

BSA Annual Conference 2023

Help spread sociology

If you like what I do please support me on Ko-fi

ADVERTISEMENT

Topics

2023 Attitudes Bibliography Blended Families British Sociological Association Compound Families Compound Family Compound Family Definition Conferences Definition of Compound Family Dictionary of Sociology Film Screening Ideology Lone-Parent Families Lone Parent Bibliography Moral Panics Neoliberalism NHS Polygamous Families Reconstituted Families Satanic Panic Single-parent Families Sociological Perspectives Sociology Documentary Sociology Family Types Sociology Guides Sociology of Crime & Deviance Sociology of Disability Sociology of Education Sociology of Film Sociology of Health Sociology of Religion Sociology of Social Media Sociology of the Family Stem Families Stepfamilies Symbolic Interactionism Totemism UBI UBI Labs Universal Basic Income Universal Basic Income Documentary What are Blended Families What are Reconstituted Familes What Are Stepfamilies
Sociology Magazine

SociologyMag brings you sociology as it occurs within the everyday. SociologyMag also serves you with guides, how-to's, and knowledge to help you succeed within academic sociology at all levels. If you are new here, check out our How to Use This Site page to get the most out of your visit.

No Result
View All Result

Highlights

Universal Basic Income

Experiences of Single-Fathers & Lone-Fathers

Attitudes Towards Single-Parents and Lone-Parents

Bibliography: Perceptions and Attitudes to Single-Parents & Lone-Parents

Single-Mother

Bibliography: Stepfamilies

Trending

Adult hands and baby feet representing a multi-ethnic family
Sociology of Family

List of Family Types in Sociology

by Dr Brian Waldock
July 27, 2023
2

There are many family types in sociology and they get confusing very quickly. Here, I try to...

Mother and daughter using a computer and internet during mother working from home

What Are Lone-Parent and Single-Parent Families?

October 30, 2023
Colourised picture of two families

What Are Stepfamilies, Reconstituted Families, and Blended Families?

August 15, 2023
Laughing at refugees

Tyranny of the Laughing Emoji

June 19, 2023
A stsatue of Karl Marx in Chemnitz

What is Marxism?

January 25, 2023

SociologyMag is an educational website designed to bring sociology to a wider audience. We look at how sociology can be used in the everyday by creating content which draws on academic sociology. We also target sociology from the academic side by publishing articles to help students at all levels from beginner to PhD.

Follow us on social media:

© 2022 SociologyMag

No Result
View All Result
  • Everyday Sociology
  • Academic Sociology
    • Subject Areas
      • Sociological Perspectives
      • Sociology of Crime & Deviance
      • Sociology of Disability
      • Sociology of Education
      • Sociology of Family
      • Sociology of Body & Health
      • Sociology of Identity
      • Sociology of Inequalities
      • Sociology of Media
      • Sociology of Power
      • Sociology of Race & Ethnicity
      • Sociology of Religion
      • Sociology of Sexuality & Gender
      • Sociology of Social Exclusion
      • Sociology of Social Movements
      • Sociology of Stratification
      • Sociology of Technology
      • Sociology of Work
    • Research Methods
    • Guides & How To’s
    • Publications & Resources
      • Bibliographies
    • Conferences & Events
  • The Interlocutor
  • Dictionary
    • A
    • B
    • C
    • D
    • E
    • F
    • G
    • H
    • I
    • J
    • K
    • L
    • M
    • N
    • O
    • P
    • Q
    • R
    • S
    • T
    • U
    • V
    • W
    • X
    • Y
    • Z
  • About
    • How to Use This Site
    • Write For Us
    • FAQ
    • Contact Us

© 2022 SociologyMag